The left is on the wrong side, the anti w0rker side on this.
The right to work movement restores the right to choose union membership to working people. That's all it is. There are some powerful wealthy interests who gain from forcibly extracted dues money who oppose this.
Pass right to work across the nation. Let unions thrive because workers want to be in them. not because they are forced to against their will and interest.
There is nothing "extreme" about this idea. No one forces you to join the NRA, do they? Is it "extreme" to prevent them from forcing you to?
Medical: You don't need ID to go to the emergency room (which is what the poor do when they need medical care), let alone a photo ID
Job: you don't need a PHOTO ID to apply for a job (have you ever been asked for one? I never have, nor have I ever even heard of anyone who couldn't apply for or get a job due to the lack of one (unless it was a requirement of the job, such as bus driver). You can get a job with a Social Security Card (which you would have from birth), and a voter registration card (see note below). Also, it's estimated that 30% of US income is on a cash-in-hand basis, where (of course), no formal application of employment is ever made.
Welfare benefits: you don't generally need a PHOTO ID to get these. For example, in North Carolina you can use any two of these: Rent receipt, Utility bill, Documentation from an employer, Tax records ,Registration with an employment agency, Written declaration from collateral contact (I,e, someone who can confirm who you are), N.C. school records diploma, voter registration card none of which require a PHOTO ID (note: that last only requires a Social Security Card, and does not by itself allow you to vote). If you don't need a PHOTO ID to get the benefits, then common sense and logic says you wouldn't need one to use them.
Here's another wrinkle: To get a Voter ID in Wisconsin you need a copy of your birth certificate. But to get a copy of your birth certificate, you need:
ONE of the following:
Wisconsin driver's license
Wisconsin ID card
Out-of-state driver's license/ID card
OR
TWO of the following:
U.S. government-issued photo ID
Passport
Checkbook/bank statement
Health insurance card
Current, dated, signed lease
Utility bill or traffic ticket
Paycheck or earnings statement
So if you have no photo ID to begin with, that knocks down the first list .
You can't get a bank account because no photo ID, so there goes the first three of the second list.
You're too poor to buy health insurance and you don't live in a state that has expanded Medicaid to all through the ACA (WI is one of the 26 states which haven't), so no health insurance card.
That means you need two of the three left.
If you are unemployed, employed on a cash basis, or retired and
renting but your name is not on the lease, or
renting but your name is not on the utility bills, or
renting and utilities are included in the rent,
living somewhere but not paying rent by someone's good graces,
homeless,
living in a nursing home and having someone else taking care of your rent and utilities or
disabled in such a way that you need to have someone else take care of your rent and utilities
then you're screwed.
Flights: the answer is, they don't fly. if you're scraping by on $7.25 an hour (or on a fixed income, or are unemployed) you're not travelling much (if at all) , and if you are, you're taking the bus, which doesn't require an ID.
Alcohol: First, your question doesn't apply to those who can vote but are not of legal drinking age - in WI, that's 200,000 people; Second, how many stores ask for an ID from someone with gray hair and wrinkles (there are at least 1.3 million seniors in WI)? ; Third, one could easily envision a situation where one person in group has an ID and purchases it for the rest you can make your own alcoholic beverages much more cheaply (and get the ingredients without an ID) and government simply doesn't have the resources to police every neighborhood in order to stop you from consuming and/or selling it.
If your income (before taxes) is $59 a day, you're not taking a half-day off work to go to the DMV, and then spending another half-day's income to get a photo ID unless you absolutely need to.
As Pope, I believe it should be his concern how we treat and protect all God's creations, not the one's man created. If it's political it certainly isn't because the Holy Father made it so.
Pages